Building a solidarity ecosystem for AI ⊗ Dawn of the electric world order
No.403 — Being harvested by the future ⊗ The impact of AI-generated text ⊗ Paris staged a huge stress test for extreme heat ⊗ Mesmerizing cat-5 super typhoon
Building a solidarity ecosystem for AI
I’ve mentioned the Holly Herndon interview where she uses the term “collective intelligence.” She uses it more as a lens on AI, a way of considering what’s in there and, to a certain degree, how one might interact with LLMs. In this piece by R. Trebor Scholz and Mark Esposito however, we have a well put framework to actually build collective intelligence, in the sense LLMs built with alternative infrastructure, ownership, and democratic governance. They remind us that AI’s harms are structural, not incidental. The current AI economy operates as a vertically integrated “extraction stack”—hardware, cloud infrastructure, models, labour, and applications—controlled by a handful of corporations whose ownership models and technical architectures make ethical guidelines largely irrelevant. Regulation of dominant platforms is necessary but insufficient; as long as the underlying infrastructure remains privately held, democratic AI is impossible. The alternative they propose is reclaiming that stack layer by layer through cooperatives, public institutions, and social movements—reframing AI not as an autonomous force but as something built on human labour and communal knowledge.
The authors identify three shifts required to make the solidarity stack durable rather than merely aspirational. The first is public-cooperative partnerships that give alternative models real-world testing environments—municipalities working with cooperatives to trial community-governed AI services before broader deployment. The second is investment in federated learning and open models, so cooperatives can train algorithms locally without centralising data, and shared protocols can let community-owned platforms interoperate at scale without a corporate intermediary. The third is cross-movement alliance-building, connecting councils, civil society groups, and technologists around shared political commitments that can actually shape procurement standards and policy agendas.
The Melon Husks and the Scam Altmans are strident and have access to huge platforms, including media taking their spiel for granted (they’ll be critical, but take the predictions as givens). Near the end, Scholz and Esposito write that “the dominant AI narrative falsely suggests that centralized corporate control is inevitable.” The technical possibilities are intriguing, the potential for curtailing—or at least building options to—the tech giants is enticing, but alongside the hard challenges of projects of that scale and complexity, it’s also worth noting another potent example of inventing and talking about better futures.
At the knowledge level, access to AI alone is insufficient if the tools operate as black boxes that cannot explain or be challenged in their outputs and that are grounded in imposed rather than democratically established values. The solidarity approach responds by reclaiming the knowledge layer as a collectively governed space—one that favors explainability, contestability, shared standards, and deep AI literacy. […]
AI systems are built on ownership models, supply chains, and technical architectures that prioritize profit, scale, and control. These structural incentives determine how data is collected, how labor is treated, who makes decisions, and who captures value, leaving ethical guidelines with no power to override the system’s underlying logic. […]
MIDATA demonstrates that creating high-quality, ethically sourced datasets is possible without surveillance; members willingly share their data because they trust the cooperative’s governance and data stewardship, eliminating the need for extraction or coercive monitoring. […]
Federated learning allows cooperatives to leverage AI while maintaining privacy by training algorithms locally rather than centralizing data. Shared protocols can further facilitate the technical integration of these efforts by providing the framework for a decentralized ecosystem of community-owned platforms.