Building the “New Equilibrium” economy ⊗ Let the Internet die
No.425 — Palestinian diaspora futures ⊗ Reverse Engineer Anything ⊗ The polar vortex is about to go haywire ⊗ Giant eagles once ruled the skies
Building the “New Equilibrium” economy
In Noema, Philipp Humm begins by looking at Aristotle’s self-weaving loom, a thought experiment about what would happen to masters and servants if tools could work on their own, and asks what becomes of societies built on wage labour once AI and robots make that labour less necessary. He points to a contradiction in current policy: governments spend heavily to make up for shrinking workforces, through family subsidies and immigration, while investing just as heavily in technologies meant to need fewer workers. South Korea, with a fertility rate around 0.75, is also the most robot-dense economy in the world. Humm looks back on how work became the organising principle of modern life, from Adam Smith to Henry Ford paying his workers enough to buy the cars they built, so that wages came to fund taxes, pensions and consumption all at once. AI threatens that arrangement because it automates the cognitive work people used to move into when machines took over physical tasks, what Erik Brynjolfsson calls the “Turing Trap.” Humm considers a 30% drop in employment over the coming decades plausible.
I’ve often wondered if an ageing, shrinking population and automation could cancel each other out, so I was glad to see Humm build part of his essay on that idea. His “30/30 equilibrium” imagines population and labour demand both falling by about 30%, which would keep the ratio of workers to everyone else roughly where it is today. That steadies the economy without making anyone better off; prosperity would depend on more and better machines for each remaining worker, what economists call capital deepening, and he calculates that a 45% gain in capital productivity would keep GDP flat while raising GDP per person by more than 40%. What he doesn’t consider is that 30% fewer people should also mean about 30% less consumption, perhaps more once climate adaptation takes its share, which might make keeping GDP stable less necessary than he assumes.
According to his line of thought, cheaper intelligence will mean more consumption of everything, as Jevons saw with coal, so a smaller population living better is the more sustainable path, an economy leaving its fast-growing pioneer phase for a mature “climax society.” He would need to say what “living better” means there, and abundant solar power belongs next to robotic recycling and precision fermentation in his list of what could make prosperity less material. I’ve come back to it a few times through Deb Chachra’s idea of abundant energy and her essay on what cheap energy does to materials, which is precisely what recycling at scale would need.
The question that follows is who gets the surplus. If machines replace workers, income shifts to whoever owns the models, data centres and energy systems, and the economy loses customers who can afford what it makes. Humm sees UBI (universal basic income) as useful during the transition but a poor permanent settlement: financed by debt or by taxes on production, he argues, it would feed inflation, and he recalls England’s Speenhamland system of 1795, which ended up subsidising low wages. His alternative draws on Marx’s “general intellect.” AI is built on what he calls a “civilizational commons”: it is trained on humanity’s accumulated knowledge and runs on publicly funded research, universities, networks and energy systems. The public should therefore hold equity in it, in effect charging these companies for their use of everything society has built, and pay citizens a universal capital dividend, making the seamstress “a shareholder in the loom rather than a dependent of the state.” He closes with two problems that would survive even a successful transition: Hannah Arendt’s “worldlessness,” the loss of meaning and public life once work no longer organises them, and the gradual handover of judgment to systems built to optimise, the choice between becoming Homo curans, people freed to care for each other and the world, and Homo algorithmus, second-class decision-makers in a world optimised by machines.
Artificial intelligence forces us to confront this issue anew: What becomes of a society whose economy, purpose and welfare state are built on wage labor if wage labor loses that foundational role? Perhaps the true AI revolution will begin in our conception of what it means to be human, not inside Silicon Valley’s data centers. […]
A “shrinking-rich economy” may ultimately require a monetary and financial system that derives its stability less from ever-expanding debt than from the growing productivity of capital. […]
Ecology offers a useful framework. The ecologist Eugene Odum distinguished between pioneer and climax ecosystems. Young forests grow aggressively, consume resources and prioritize speed over sustainability. Mature forests grow little yet contain far greater biomass, complexity, stability and resilience than the pioneer systems from which they emerged. […]
Artificial intelligence gives this idea a literal technological form. AI models are not created in a vacuum. They are trained on the accumulated intellectual inheritance of humanity: books, scientific papers, Wikipedia entries, forum discussions, software libraries, images, public archives, open-source code and countless traces of human communication. They also depend on publicly funded research, energy infrastructure, universities, telecommunications networks, roads, water systems and legal protections. The intelligence economy is built by both private firms and a civilizational commons.
Let the Internet die. Then what?
Responding to Miles Klee’s WIRED piece on John West’s book The Internet Will Die, and So Will You, Daniel Harvey agrees that the attention-driven internet is rotting but finds the proposed remedy too thin. He argued in 2018 that outrage was a business model, and he sees generative AI as the step that completes it: anger no longer needs angry people once bots can produce it, and security firms now count more automated traffic online than human. Add the link rot West documents, and the web looks less like a permanent library than a series of rented rooms. Klee suggests withdrawing, leaving the platforms for dead. Harvey heard the same advice from Jaron Lanier years ago and still finds it incomplete, since many people depend on those platforms for work, family or organising, and a boycott starves little when much of the audience is already automated. What he keeps from West are the overlooked corners, small and unoptimised places where people make things with no money at stake. For him, enormous scale is a requirement of advertising. The fixes are to charge people honestly, build products that end, make what people create portable, and stop measuring success by how often users come back.
Harvey is specific about what should die: the rage-bait farms, the bot swarms and the attention merchants, in other words the platforms that happen to run on the internet. That distinction deserves more weight than the “let it die” framing gives it. The internet used to be closer to a commons, then became mostly commercial, and now the commercial part is overrun with slop and bots. Saying “the internet” should die skips the first step and accepts the platforms’ claim that they are the internet. Declare the whole thing dead and we lose more than the original web; we give up on the idea of a free, citizen-led place online, which suits the broligarchs and minor hustlers who wrecked it just fine. It becomes one more step in the extraction of everything. Harvey’s remedies come from someone who builds products, and they are good ones, but a well-designed paid service is still not a commons. The noncommercial corners he and West both value are what remains of that commons, and they need defending and maintaining before anyone writes their obituary.
Outrage was always a profitable commodity, but it had a supply problem. Somebody had to be angry, and humans are slow, inconsistent, and occasionally go outside. They get tired. They log off for dinner. […]
And the people running the platforms have helped. Klee notes that the billionaires who own them rolled back moderation, which opened the floodgates to inauthentic activity, conspiracy-mongering, and hate speech. That’s not a failure of the system. Slop is cheap, slop is infinite, and slop keeps the numbers going up. […]
When I was at The Dots our model was mostly recruitment revenue, and that freed us to design things differently. Nobody had to visit five times a day. There was no infinite scroll. You could finish the experience, close the tab, and get on with your life. Closure and completeness are design choices, and they only become available when the business doesn’t need you to stay. […]
Compost only works if somebody’s thought about the garden. That means business models that don’t depend on harvesting attention, funding for small communities, and tools that let you export what you made and take it with you when the landlord changes the locks.
If you’d like to support the newsletter, please share it with a friend or colleague who you think might enjoy it. I appreciate the help!
Futures, Fictions & Fabulations
- Textile Futures 2040. “Textile Futures 2040 is a project developed by Forum for the Future, supported by the H&M Foundation, that examines the plausible futures towards which the global textile industry may be moving. Building on more than a decade of futures work in the sector, including the earlier Fashion Futures scenarios, the project responds to a moment of significant uncertainty. In conditions of rapid change, planning for a single expected future is insufficient.”
- Palestinian diaspora futures, 2040–2050. “The article considers the use of CLA in conjunction with the Futures Triangle and the process of scenario building to shed light on the tension between preferred, plausible and probable futures of Palestinian exiles over 2040–2050 and the implications these futures have for European anticipatory governance.”
- Too Much Future: Five essays on the age of Big Futurity by Tracey Follows. “What happens when a futurist begins to wonder whether we have too much future?”
Algorithms, Automations & Augmentations
- Reverse engineer anything: AI companies crack down on the coolest thing people were doing with AI. “AI-powered copyright circumvention is OK with big tech when it’s a massive company scraping the entire internet to build their LLMs, but is not OK when people then use those tools to liberate their internet-of-things devices.”
- What are AI’s emissions, energy use? “AI’s climate footprint varies widely by model and task, and pressure is growing on tech companies to disclose more about their energy use and emissions.” (archive.ph)
- Google DeepMind mathematically verified key parts of Signal. “Or ‘formally verify,’ a number of the Signal protocol’s key cryptographic guarantees—a landmark development for the widely used cryptography and AI itself.”
Built, Biosphere & Breakthroughs
- The polar vortex is about to go haywire. “What that means for our weather forecast in the U.S. is still unclear. It’s an El Niño year, so meteorologists had expected winter in North America to be relatively mild. A polar vortex split could bring cooler temperatures across the continent in the coming weeks, but exactly when and where that will happen—and whether it will happen at all—remain unanswered.”
- How to build an entire city out of timber? “Oskar Norelius of White Arkitekter discusses the studio's considerate approach, building with wood at scale, current projects and why trying something new is worth it”
- Giant “heat storms” are scorching the Earth. This is the story of the biggest one on record. Those maps are terrifying. “Supersized heat waves used to be rare. No longer. A Reuters data-driven examination of global temperatures reveals the emergence of what we call ‘heat storms.’ They now swarm the planet, upending life around the world from Texas to Ivory Coast to Poland.”
Asides
- Giant eagles once ruled the skies. Charismatic megafauna FTW! “For tens of millions of years, between the fall of the non-avian dinosaurs and the Great Ice Age, the skies were ruled by these giants. Their reign may have shaped the course of human evolution in profound and overlooked ways. Some are thought to have left their mark in legends of child-snatching birds that have lived on in cultures around the world, long after the birds themselves died out.”
- What an iceberg looks like from underneath. “Tobias Friedrich cut a hole in a frozen Greenland fjord and dove under it to photograph the part of an iceberg we never see.”
- Every SpaceX Starlink satellite has to dodge a collision almost weekly, and experts fear the worst. “I think we're heading towards a situation where there will be a collision involving an operational satellite in the constellation.” Reminder; Kessler syndrome.
“Ambitious, thoughtful, constructive, and dissimilar to most others.
I get a lot of value from Sentiers.”
If this resonates, please consider becoming a supporting member—it keeps this work independent.