Neuroplasticity as a praxis ⊗ The Ambiguist

No.413 — The science of foresight ⊗ Librarians are hosting viral “Avoiding AI” workshops ⊗ What if we never built another new building? ⊗ Seoul’s outdoor library

Neuroplasticity as a praxis ⊗ The Ambiguist
I’ve been enjoying this very active anarchist tagger’s work in my neighbourhood.

Now that heatwave season has ended (right??) in the northern hemisphere, time to get back to some newslettering. Thanks to the few people who reached out saying they missed their Sunday morning fix, that was great to read.

I don’t currently have a work/consultancy/client page on the Sentiers website and the description and “work shapes” listed on my personal page are woefully out of date—although they still give a pretty good sampling. You probably already guessed that I’m mentioning this because, like many an indie consultant, I have availability for client work!!

Foresight research; “observation research” (look on the about page for more, although I do need to write that up in more detail); writing of briefings, reports, monthly readings, etc.; “applied foresight,” a term I use for signals and trends research within innovation teams, for prototyping instead of reports. Basically, if you have questions about anything you’ve read about in the newsletter and want to dig deeper, I can provide some answers and do some of the digging for you. Hit me up at patrick@sentiers.media.

Last bit of (pre)promo: a couple of people have asked me for mentoring in the use of AI in knowledge work. I’m thinking of setting that up, it would look something like four calls, one every two weeks or month. On the first call I give you some details about how I work and potentially a few tools (Claude skills, documents, etc.), then we proceed by socratic dialogue (ok, I just mean Q&A ;-)), and perhaps a little homework/mini-mission to look into before your next call. If that sounds like something you might need, the address is above to show interest and offer feedback. If I go ahead, there should be more details coming over the next fortnight or so. It could also look like a group call at the same kind of frequency, but I’m unsure what the pricing of that might look like. Feedback welcome.


Neuroplasticity as a praxis

Matt Seybold expands on a reading list proposed by Tressie McMillan Cottom in a recent New York Times piece (see below this article’s quotes): a set of books, mostly by journalists and public scholars, addressing how technology, politics, and money are reshaping the present. Seybold’s own list, shared months earlier on Bluesky, first inspired Cottom’s, a conversation, like in the good old days of blogging… but not on blogs. His interest, though, is less in which books make the cut than in what she proposes doing with them. Reading these works closely, he argues, is not preparation for action but a form of action itself—a way of exposing that the difficulty of reading deeply, listening carefully, and talking about the present has been manufactured rather than inherited. He traces this argument back through Nicholas Carr and Maryanne Wolf, whose research on neuroplasticity showed that reading circuits in the brain are built, not given, and therefore fragile. Where Carr and Wolf worried in the 2010s about digital media reshaping cognition, Seybold believes that they underestimated how deliberately that reshaping would later be pursued: tech companies built products to be addictive, monetised that addiction, and enclosed the information people needed inside those same harmful products.

Seybold also writes about what he calls deliberate “deliteracy,” the restriction and monopolisation of the conditions that make mass literacy possible, wielded as a strategy for consolidating power. Wolf’s claim that reading circuits require collective, institutional maintenance becomes, in his reading, a democratic requirement under direct attack. His conclusion, correctly in my opinion, goes beyond private reading habits and towards organising: neuroplasticity only becomes a counterbalancing force if it scales into book clubs, discussion groups, and lending circles, rather than simply being seen as an individual practice. (Also check out the combined long list at the bottom, offered as raw material for that kind of organising, rather than a fixed canon.)

At one time in history these might have been relatively standard practices for readers of the New York Times. But these days I see little evidence that deep reading, careful listening, and critical conversation about our present epoch regularly take place. There is no reason it must be that way. But one thing that will happen if you do what Cottom prescribes is that you’ll figure out that it did not become that way by accident. […]

It is a type of direct action because one of the things which will become apparent as you read the books Cottom is recommending is that powerful forces are aligned against the practices of reading books, listening to researchers, and discussing why this period in our history is the way it is (and why maybe the next one doesn’t have to be). Deep reading, careful listening, and constructive conversing are harder to do than they used to be. […]

Unlike speech, is not a foregone conclusion that mass literacy will endure from generation to generation. And we may be shocked by what cognitive and affective capacities disappear if human communities stop doing the hard work of building reading circuits within their members.

§ I picked Seybold’s piece because of the neuroplasticity angle, but Cottom’s is also worth a read. She frames the same urgency in more explicitly political terms. She argues that AI isn’t a product but a political theory, and needs a vocabulary of its own: data politics. “All of the speculation and hype around A.I. is hiding the fact that the technology isn’t just large language models or agents or data centers. It is the backbone of a superstructure that merges regressive politics with unchecked economic power in the guise of technological innovation. Put simply, there is too much money, some of it too untraceable, giving a small group of unelected people too much power over the people. That’s data politics.”

Your Futures Thinking Observatory