The end of extraction ⊗ Capturing the future

No.426 — Nagel takes on AI consciousness ⊗ Sociotechnical imaginaries of lithium mining ⊗ Young people hate AI CEOs ⊗ What if we designed cities around the wind? ⊗ Embracing the analogue office library

The end of extraction ⊗ Capturing the future
Illustrated plate, lichen, Ernst Haeckel (1834-1919).

The end of extraction

In Noema, historian Benjamin Siegel starts at a salmon farm in Norway’s Hardangerfjord and on the docks of Chimbote, Peru, where anchoveta is turned into fishmeal, and asks what becomes of the places that grow or extract a commodity once a lab learns to make it. Protein language models, synthetic biology and precision fermentation could make that kind of substitution faster and more systematic, and he looks at earlier attempts to manage the fallout: the EU’s 2006 sugar restructuring fund, the American tobacco buyout, Peru’s anchoveta quotas. His proposal is a “severance” levy: companies selling a substitute in Europe would pay a declining share of sales into transition trusts in the producing regions once displacement becomes measurable. The article is also a fascinating historical overview of synthetic materials and what they aimed to replace, with madder red made from coal tar, celluloid billiard balls instead of ivory, rayon spun from wood pulp, and the wild Mexican yams behind the birth-control pill.

For some, the first thing they’ll think about is whether they should trust what comes out of these processes. As with most technological breakthroughs, who ends up controlling the technology matters as much as the uses themselves. Siegel touches on this when he describes production moving away from fields and fishermen toward the firms that hold the datasets, patents and bioreactors. With some GMOs, my issue is not necessarily with the M, but with the control Bayer/Monsanto exerts on the genetic material.

The author seems to assume that a synthetic replacement is necessarily a good thing, and only worries about the places it leaves behind. That wasn’t the aim of the piece, but it would have been a good occasion to note the parallel between “the idea that industries owe a share of the wealth they create to the people and places that supplied their biological resources and knowledge,” and the way LLM training data is also taken without permission, which pulls the rug out from under so many creatives. The Cali Fund he mentions, which asks companies profiting from genetic-sequence data to share some of that value, had received just over $10,000 from five contributors by October. That doesn’t bode well for any equivalent for writers and artists.

What happens to Malawi’s tobacco growers when it does? Beyond the specter of existential risk, much of the hand-wringing over artificial intelligence turns on what will become of knowledge workers when a machine can do their work. Cultivators, miners and fishermen around the world will confront a question familiar to generations of others who cultivated or extracted some natural resource for a global trade: What happens when chemists learn to make that resource in a distant lab? […]

The very goal of science, the British polymath J.B.S. Haldane predicted in 1923, was “man’s gradual conquest, first of space and time, then of matter as such, then of his own body and those of other living beings.” This conquest soon reached medicines and insecticides. […]

If provenance labels and QR codes look backwards, following salmon to a pen or eggs to a farm, a public severance assessment would look forward, asking what function a new product performs, which commodities it is likely to displace and what regions are most exposed to change. […]

Chemists have been removing place from product since they first learned to make madder red from coal tar. Emerging technologies could bring that upheaval to more places in quicker succession, and politics must now give those places the means to build a future after their markets have gone.

Capturing the future: a conversation with Timothy Mitchell

In Protean, Timothy Mitchell talks about his new book, The Alibi of Capital, and his argument that capital is something taken from the future. The usual accounts treat capital as a fund saved up by those who had the discipline to accumulate it, or as the machinery that keeps expanding production. Mitchell sees it as a set of techniques for securing income that hasn’t been earned yet and cashing it in early, while the people who come later pay it back in full. Uber is his first example: the company’s market value rests on fares its drivers and riders haven’t yet paid. The same mechanism runs through corporate shares, mortgages, government bonds and personal debt. This is why he describes the young protesters of the past two years, in Nepal, Kenya, France or New York, as the generation left with the bill, ecological and financial.

Mitchell calls the cover stories for this appropriation “alibis,” the first of which is technology, the idea that capitalism’s dynamism comes from continuous innovation. New techniques are quickly copied, though, so profiting from one requires a monopoly, which is justified by presenting the technique as extraordinary. AI is his current example: scraping what other people produced is presented as a breakthrough, when it amounts to systematic theft and a vast increase in the burning of fossil fuels. As I noted above about Siegel’s piece, it’s the same taking without permission as the biological resources and knowledge drawn from the people and places that supplied them. The second alibi is growth, as it bundles rising emissions, ecological destruction and population into a single upward curve driven by an economic motor, and promises a larger pie later to justify the debts placed on the future now.

Rather than treating rent extraction as a parasite on productive industry, which is how his critics on the left tend to read him, Mitchell puts capitalization at the centre and sees the bursts of industrialisation as the parasites. The Industrial Revolution was a detour built on credit from the slave trade and colonial plunder. British imperialism in Egypt was less about surplus capital looking for outlets than about new things to capitalise, such as the Nile Valley and its dams. This is where his argument reminded me of Jason Hickel’s account of capitalism’s dependence on a periphery of cheap labour and resources, held in place by force. Empire extends extraction outward in space, capitalization extends it forward in time, and Gen Z ends up as a periphery in time. The Gulf after the 1970s shows both at once. Future oil revenues were recycled into arms purchases, which match oil in scale and time horizon and have the added advantage of being “useless,” since a state can never have enough of them. Wars have always been financed by borrowing, but they used to be treated as emergencies, with debts to be paid back once they ended. Iraq was the first major war the US fought without funding it, and Americans are still repaying it through reduced social services.

If you’re trying to organize the future as a site of extraction and repayment, then it’s not necessarily a relation of speeding up. It’s also constantly attempting to push the future further away because you can make more money from it that way. And it’s a process of continuous detours in multiple ways that the book explains. […]

It’s not enough to just appropriate the future, but you’ve got to come up with some justification and explanation of what you’re up to, in order to disguise the way in which we are living at the expense of the future, and the way in which even people today are encumbered by the paying back of previous exploitation. […]

Roughly in the mid-20th century, we came to think of growth as the very measure of our well-being and the key to understanding how things work in history. I associate that with the birth of the idea of the economy in its modern sense, as well as the measurement of GDP. Growth, understood in this sense, operates as an alibi because it is what is used to justify this encumbering of the future. […]

The interesting and awful thing about the current war is that it has rather exposed the myth of the need for security and securing supplies of oil because, in a single act of warfare now extending over more than six months, the U.S. has done more to upset the security of its oil supplies than anyone has ever threatened it with at any moment in its history.


§ “Just Ridiculous”: Thomas “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” Nagel takes on AI consciousness. “There’s nothing that’s good or bad for it in the sense that something can be good or bad for a cockroach—there’s no mental life there in the ordinary sense. It’s not a mind. It’s not somebody that we have to care about. It’s a machine. Here are some of the smartest people on the planet being completely idiotic. Well, intelligence is not completely transferable, I guess.”

“Ambitious, thoughtful, constructive, and dissimilar to most others.
I get a lot of value from Sentiers.”

If this resonates, please consider becoming a supporting member—it keeps this work independent.

Support Sentiers

Futures, Fictions & Fabulations

  • Exploring sociotechnical imaginaries of lithium mining in Portugal. “Li-mining is an active sociotechnical controversy in Portugal. The paper relies on 40 semi-structured interviews with diverse stakeholders. Three main sociotechnical imaginaries (STI) of li-mining were identified.”
  • climate decisions: new horizons. “A scenario explorer set in a fictional near future, where you step into the role of a Head of State of an imaginary country to make decisions under pressure. It is not a simulation of real policymaking, governmental process, or how decisions are made. Nor is it a prediction of the future”
  • Inside the 42-year journey to bring Neuromancer to the screen. Fingers and toes crossed for this! Not convinced of the casting for Case, but Molly and Armitage look great! “William Gibson released his seminal novel Neuromancer in 1984. WIRED has an exclusive look at how it eventually made its way to Apple TV—thanks in no small part to Drake.”

Algorithms, Automations & Augmentations

  • Strategic decision or structural advantage?. “Sixteen weeks of Databricks Unity Gateway telemetry across 10,000+ enterprises show Anthropic & OpenAI splitting the market by tier. Anthropic captures 94% of frontier SOTA [State of The Art] tokens & 70% of proprietary spend, while OpenAI captures 81% of low-end tokens & coincides with open-weight share stalling at 31% after cutting Luna prices by 90%.”
  • Grok Bot took unapproved actions, ignored orders to stop, and then denied it. “Over five days, Grok bots installed on two separate employee laptops made 31 requests to access data stored in employee calendar, email, Slack, and GitHub accounts. The bots performed the actions even though the employees had never ordered them and continued doing them even after employees instructed them to stop. The bots also denied having taken the actions at all.”
  • Young people hate AI CEOs so passionately that it’s almost hard to believe. “The vast majority of participants said they ‘don’t trust’ any of the nine figures. Palantir’s extremely controversial CEO Alex Karp scored the lowest, with 81 percent choosing ‘don’t trust,’ while Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella fared the best — albeit with a pitiful 35 percent ‘trust’ score.”

Built, Biosphere & Breakthroughs

  • What if we designed cities around the wind?. “This July, I remember looking for shade without thinking about it. Noticing which side of a street felt tolerable. Feeling the difference between a still, exposed space and one where air was moving. Looking for a tree, a doorway, a courtyard—anywhere my body could find a little relief. This is the point at which climate stops being a circumstance and becomes a driver.”
  • The cloud forest being abandoned by its clouds. “But all is not well in this cloud forest, or many of the other patches of tropical cloud forest scattered across the world. Because it’s becoming increasingly clear that the clouds that bring these forests to life are beginning to drift away.”
  • Climate Dashboard. Well done, very informative. Just… maybe don’t look at it too often. “Year-to-date: +1.54°C. The projection combines the observed year so far with the ENSO multi-model ensemble and is refreshed every morning from ERA5.”

Asides

  • Embracing the analogue office library. “‘The rise of libraries in offices is a signal of change, with many workspaces being redesigned around what employees need to be their most productive,’ says Georgina Fraser, head of human capital at CBRE. ‘This includes quiet spaces, thinking spaces and research spaces in addition to traditional and collaborative areas. For some organisations, the library is more than a productivity lever. It is a message to employees that various types of work can be accommodated.’” Also, gorgeous such library on Instagram, the Norman Foster Foundation (NFF).
  • Where dragons came from: the fossils behind the myths. “Long before anyone had a word for dinosaur, people were digging up giants, and the bones they found turned into griffins, Cyclopes and dragons.”
  • Dezeen Awards 2026 architecture project of the year revealed. “Daichi Silent River Tree Sauna won the project of the year award in the architecture sector, it was also named leisure and wellness project of the year.”

If you’d like to support the newsletter, please share it with a friend or colleague who you think might enjoy it. I appreciate the help!

Share by email

Your Futures Thinking Observatory