Towards kindred futures ⊗ What more-than-human really means
No.417 — The map fiction missed ⊗ Cognitive integrity ⊗ The massive layer of life just beneath our feet ⊗ NASA’s Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope
Towards kindred futures
Ana Sun, writing in Vector, asks why everyday speech treats “the future” as singular when—as we’ve covered here abundantly—many are possible, and whether that habit makes climate collapse feel like destiny. Science fiction was meant to widen the view. Ursula K. Le Guin held that “science fiction is not predictive; it is descriptive,” and Istvan Csicsery-Ronay calls it “imaginary prediction,” a way to explore and question forecasts. Sun argues that its cautionary tales have instead become “ingrained blueprints” for the powerful, and that the genre now needs to serve as a tool for deliberate imagination.
Sun also looks at why distant futures are hard to picture at all, and the answer lies partly in how memory works. Daniel Kahneman’s “remembering self” is “a storyteller” that discards lived moments and keeps a narrative, and Martin Conway and Catherine Loveday find that remembering the past and imagining the future rely on the same system. Both blur with distance, like a “fish-eye lens,” so a distant goal such as a stable climate lacks the cues of a doughnut in a shop window. I’m just skimming over this to focus on the angle below, but it’s a great section of the piece that you should also look into.
What I hadn’t heard of before, and found the most important to share, is the six orientations Rebecca Bryant and Daniel M. Knight propose in The Anthropology of the Future. Destiny is a future that arrives regardless of what happens in between—the stance Sun suspects many have adopted toward climate breakdown and an inequitable AI future. Expectation leans on past experience, like taking an umbrella “just in case” because forecasts have been wrong before; it grounds the present in what has already happened. Anticipation “slims the present” and draws the future into current activity, like smelling rain and closing the windows. Speculation sits in the gap between the two, when information is partial; the UK’s bet on a mix of nuclear, geothermal, solar and wind is her example. Potentiality is rooted in things already set in motion, such as the solar farms she counts on a train to North Wales. Bryant and Knight place hope “in the gap between the potential and the actual,” though Sun prefers Rebecca Solnit’s version: “hope is an ax you break down doors with in an emergency.”
Sun argues that hope has to be collective to matter, and points to Rob Hopkins’s “collective mental time travel”: groups assemble visions of the future out of shared memories, so creating those memories on purpose gives a community more material to imagine with. In her account, this is how people “reclaim our agency from the illusion of destiny” and move toward what she calls “kindred futures.”
It would be interesting to see how the six orientations could be combined with the Voros futures cone. Perhaps the cone to locate a future by how plausible or likely it seems, and the orientations to describe how people hold that future and act on it in the present?
Have we inadvertently accepted a destiny described by cyberpunk, a future rocket-boosted by uncaring technology, systems of oppression and power concentrated in the hands of a few? In Zoefuturistic terms, have we simply accepted the ‘being’ and forfeited the ‘becoming’? […]
Consider the supposedly more progressive works of authors like Simak, Asimov, Pohl Anderson, Blish, or Roddenberry. Most, if not all, of their ideas and values are realized through individualist, liberal lenses. They are mostly concerned with heroes who uphold values such as compassion, honor, duty, and virtue. They very rarely, if ever, engage with meaningful, systematic criticisms of society. […]
The idea of the supremacy of science, without engaging in its colonial roots, without engaging with ideas and problems like eugenics, without any meaningful critiques of its role in serving capitalism, is one of the main motivating powers of much of the careers cited above. […]
Hope is not like a lottery ticket you can sit on the sofa and clutch, feeling lucky. I say it because hope is an ax you break down doors with in an emergency; because hope should shove you out the door, because it will take everything you have to steer the future away from endless war, from the annihilation of the earth’s treasures and the grinding down of the poor and marginal. Hope just means another world might be possible, not promised, not guaranteed. Hope calls for action; action is impossible without hope.